Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Biblical Logic: Non Sequiturs "Denying the Antecedent"

Hebrew for Christians
BS''D
Denying the Antecedent

Definition: Any argument of the following form is invalid:

If p then q
Not p
Therefore, Not q.

Examples:

  1. If you were to get hit by a car when you are six, then you would die young. But you were not hit by a car when you were six. Thus you will not die young.

    (Of course, you could be hit by a train at age seven, in which case you still die young.)

  2. If I am in Minneapolis then I am in Minnesota.
    I am not in Minneapolis.
    Therefore, I am not in Minnesota.

    (No, I am in St. Paul, Minnesota.)

Proof: Show that even though the premises are true, the conclusion may be false. In particular, show that the consequence B may occur even though A does not occur.

References
Barker: 69, Cedarblom and Paulsen: 26, Copi and Cohen: 241